IDC Automatic Blog

Insulated vs. Uninsulated Garage Doors — Is It Worth It?

Insulated vs. Uninsulated Garage Doors — Is It Worth It?

When selecting a new garage door, homeowners often face a critical decision — should they opt for an insulated garage door or choose an uninsulated one? The answer to this question can significantly impact energy efficiency, comfort and overall functionality. Understanding the differences between these two options is essential for making an informed choice that aligns with your specific needs and climate conditions.

What Is an Insulated Garage Door?

What Is an Insulated Garage Door?

Garage door insulation maintains a comfortable indoor environment, shielding your home from the impact of external weather conditions and ultimately saving you money on heating and cooling. The benefits of insulation extend beyond just the walls of your house — they can also be harnessed for your garage.

Uninsulated garage doors, often made of a single metal or wood panel, serve as a basic barrier for your garage. While they provide some level of protection, they lack the advanced features of insulated garage doors. On the other hand, insulated garage doors boast a far superior design, consisting of two panels or a hollow door frame filled with high-quality insulating materials, such as Clopay’s cutting-edge Intellicore Insulation Technology. This technology stands out as a best-in-class solution for effective insulation.

At idc-Automatic, we use the same insulating technology in our custom garage doors. When you purchase an insulated custom garage door from idc-Automatic, you’re investing in a high-quality garage door that will give you many benefits over a single-panel, uninsulated garage door.

How Do Insulated Garage Doors Work?

Insulated garage doors work on a simple yet highly effective principle — they employ advanced materials and design techniques to create a barrier that minimizes heat transfer between the interior and exterior of the garage. This design helps maintain a more comfortable temperature within the garage and contributes to energy savings while enhancing your home’s overall energy efficiency.

By employing these sophisticated insulation techniques, insulated garage doors ensure the garage interior remains more comfortable, no matter the weather outside. Their ability to minimize heat transfer contributes to overall energy efficiency, potentially saving heating and cooling costs. The industry standards define these parameters using values such as R and U. 

Understanding R-Values and U-Values for Garage Doors

When it comes to selecting the right garage door for your home, understanding the concepts of R-values and U-values is crucial. These values play a pivotal role in determining the insulation efficiency of garage doors, helping you make an informed decision based on your specific climate and energy-saving needs.

Martin Hollaway, a green building advisor, wanted to find a way to compare the two rating systems that manufacturers use. He found that the R-value of the entire door assembly is about one-third of those for the center of the panel of that door.

So if you’re comparing doors and are confused about the R values of different garage doors, you’re not alone. Here’s a quick breakdown:

  • R-Value: An R-value is determined by the thickness of insulation and by its chemical properties. It represents the material’s resistance to heat flow — the higher the R-value, the better the door’s insulating properties.
  • Factors affecting R-Value: Many assume that an R-16 door is twice as effective at insulating as an R-8 door. While an R-16 door will provide more effective insulation, the difference is only about 5 percent. The type and thickness of insulation used in the door’s construction are significant determinants. For example, garage doors with polyurethane foam insulation tend to have higher R-values than those with polystyrene. Additionally, the door’s overall construction and design, including the number of layers and the presence of thermal breaks, influence its R-value.
  • U-Value: Some manufacturers have started to rate insulated garage doors with a U-factor instead of an R-rating. U-factors, or U-values, consider the entire assembly — frame, panels and hardware. A lower U-value signifies better insulation efficiency, indicating less heat transfer. 
  • Choosing the right R-Value and U-Value: Selecting the appropriate R-value and U-value for your garage door depends on various factors, such as your local climate, the level of insulation you desire and your energy-saving goals. For example, in colder regions, a higher R-value is often recommended to better retain heat and maintain a comfortable indoor temperature. 
  • Climate considerations: For areas with harsh winters or extreme temperatures, investing in a garage door with a higher R-value can lead to significant energy savings and improved comfort. In milder climates, a lower R-value might be sufficient. It’s essential to balance the initial investment and long-term energy savings when choosing the appropriate R-value and U-value for your garage door.
  • Sealing and weather stripping: Regardless of the R-value or U-value, a well-insulated garage door must also have proper sealing and weather stripping to prevent air leakage and drafts. 

Does Garage Door Material Impact Insulation Effectiveness? 

Different materials possess varying thermal properties, directly influencing how well the garage door can regulate temperature and protect the interior from external weather conditions:

  • Single-layer doors are made of just one layer with no added insulation
  • Double-layer doors have an added layer of insulation, usually polystyrene
  • Triple-layer doors have a thicker layer of polystyrene or polyurethane insulation and are usually the most energy-efficient

If you’re selecting a double-layer or triple-layer door, most of the insulation will be from the internal layers of polystyrene or polyurethane. That means you can choose your finish based on aesthetics instead of heat retention.

Modern garage doors usually use one of four types of materials:

  • Steel: This is the most common material for new garage doors. It’s usually chosen for its low maintenance requirements, wide variety of designs, and durability. It provides moderate insulation.
  • Aluminum: Aluminum provides a lightweight alternative to steel. Aluminum can give your garage an updated, modern look. However, it’s a poor insulator.
  • Wood: Wood offers homeowners a high-end, classic look. Wood doesn’t provide much insulation, so it’s usually chosen for appearance rather than energy efficiency.
  • Composite wood: Like wood, it’s generally not a good insulator. However, composite wood is often layered over steel and insulation in double- and triple-layer doors. It’s a popular way to get the classic appearance of wood doors with more energy efficiency.

Other Factors That Affect the Energy Efficiency of a Garage Door

Although your door’s insulation is the biggest factor in saving energy, here are a few other tips to keep in mind:

  • Choose windows carefully: The glass and acrylic used in most garage door windows tend to let a lot of heat escape. If you’re in a cold climate, consider a garage door without windows. 
  • Make sure that your door fits properly: If there are gaps between your garage door and the walls or beneath the door, an insulated door will be less effective. Make sure your door is installed properly, which will minimize these gaps. You can also install weatherstripping around the door to prevent cold air from leaking in. 
  • Invest in high-quality hardware: You can limit energy loss by making sure that your door has a high-quality track, frame, and rollers. These parts ensure that your door rolls into place with minimal gaps and air leakage.

Why We Recommend Insulated Garage Doors Over Insulation Kits

Why We Recommend Insulated Garage Doors Over Insulation Kits

We firmly advocate for insulated garage doors over insulation kits for several compelling reasons. While insulation kits might appear as a more cost-effective or straightforward solution, they often need to catch up in comparison to the benefits provided by insulated garage doors. Consider these differences:

  • Ease of installation and permanence: When you opt for an insulated door, you don’t need to go through the hassle of assembling and installing individual insulation panels, which can be time-consuming and challenging for some homeowners. The insulation is already integrated into the door during the manufacturing process, ensuring a seamless fit and hassle-free setup. Once installed, an insulated garage door remains a permanent fixture, requiring no additional adjustments.
  • Uninterrupted door operation: One significant advantage of insulated garage doors is that they do not compromise the garage door’s operation. The insulation seamlessly incorporates into the door’s construction, making it a complete and reliable unit. 
  • Superior seal and better insulation performance: Insulated garage doors are engineered with precision to provide an airtight barrier, effectively minimizing heat transfer and preventing drafts. The snug fit and advanced sealing mechanisms of insulated garage doors ensure better insulation performance, maintaining a consistent and comfortable indoor temperature within the garage. 
  • Energy efficiency and cost savings: The insulation properties of these doors contribute to reduced heat loss during winters and minimized heat gain during summers. This energy efficiency can lead to lower heating and cooling costs for the entire home, making insulated garage doors a smart investment that pays for itself over time.

Pros and Cons of Insulated Garage Doors — Are They Worth It?

Insulated garage doors come with various benefits that make them a valuable investment for many homeowners. However, like any home improvement decision, it’s essential to consider both the pros and cons before deciding whether they are worth it for your specific needs. 

What Are the Benefits of an Insulated Garage Door?

What Are the Benefits of an Insulated Garage Door?

The following are the pros of an insulated garage door:

  • Garage door insulation saves energy: The insulation layer creates a thermal barrier, preventing heat transfer between the interior and exterior of the garage. 
  • Insulated garage doors are more durable: Insulated garage doors for both residential and commercial are constructed differently from single-layer garage doors, which makes them stronger. The insulation layer in insulated garage doors often adds to their structural integrity, making them more robust and resistant to dents and damage. 
  • Insulated garage doors are quieter: Insulated garage doors offer a secondary benefit of reducing noise transmission. The foam insulation dampens vibrations and minimizes noise from street traffic, neighbors or other external sources, providing a quieter and more peaceful garage space.
  • Insulation helps to protect your car and belongings: Extreme temperatures, whether scorching heat or cold, can be detrimental to the condition of your car, tools and other items stored in the garage. Insulated garage doors help maintain a more consistent and moderate indoor temperature, shielding your valuable possessions from potential damage caused by temperature fluctuations. By minimizing exposure to extreme weather conditions, insulated garage doors contribute to preserving your car and belongings, saving you money on potential repairs or replacements.

What Are the Limitations of an Insulated Garage Door?

While insulated garage doors offer many benefits, there are certain limitations to consider before deciding. Here are some factors to consider:

  • Insulated garage doors tend to cost more: Including insulation materials and the advanced construction process contribute to the increased price tag. However, you need to weigh this cost against the long-term energy savings and potential benefits the insulation can bring.
  • Insulation is less effective on high-traffic doors: For garages with frequent openings and closings, such as those serving as a main entry point to the house or where vehicles come and go frequently, the insulation may have limited effectiveness. Each time the door opens, some of the conditioned air inside the garage may escape, reducing the overall insulation benefits. 
  • Insulation may be a lower priority for a detached garage: Detached garages are less likely to impact the house’s indoor temperature, and their primary purpose may be for vehicle storage or as a workshop. In such situations, homeowners may prioritize other factors over insulation, especially if you don’t use the garage as a living space extension.
  • Homeowners in milder climates may see less value from insulation: In regions with mild or moderate climates, the extreme temperature fluctuations that necessitate robust insulation may be less prevalent. 

Do Insulated Garage Doors Make Sense for Minnesota Homeowners?

Do Insulated Garage Doors Make Sense for Minnesota Homeowners?

idc-Automatic’s custom insulated garage doors provide the best insulating capabilities on the market. We sell top-of-the-line insulated garage doors in our semi-custom 5 Series and our fully custom, handcrafted 7 Series. We offer a full range of customization options to create the perfect garage door for your home. Get creative and trust the experts at idc-Automatic to craft the beautiful, insulated garage door you’ve always dreamed of.

We also offer various Clopay insulated garage doors. The 4-Layer Canyon Ridge® Carriage House offers a quiet, insulated and beautiful garage door that can provide protection and curb appeal to your house for years. The Canyon Ridge® Louver is another great option with its 5-layer steel base for added protection and insulation. Even Clopay’s Classic™ Steel garage doors come in multilayered options for homeowners who want a classic look with all the benefits of an insulated garage door.

You can view our full range of insulated garage doors online. Request an estimate for your Twin Cities insulated garage door today!



Subscribe to Our Newsletter